Last Word


What would a Brexit mean for the NHS?

Source: NHE May/Jun 16

 RRB6624Jane Payling, head of health and integration at the Chartered Institute of Public Finance and Accountancy (CIPFA), discusses the lack of public awareness on how the EU affects health and social care ahead of this month’s Referendum.

As the EU Referendum fast approaches, campaigners from Vote Leave have been touring the country in a battle bus which has stuck on its side, in giant letters, the claim that leaving the EU could free up £350m a week for the NHS. Unsurprisingly, Britain Stronger In has disputed this figure, arguing that it is misleading and inaccurate. This is because it ignores funding which returns to the UK through our rebate, and specific EU support to both the public and private sectors. 

Indeed, as the bus continues to tour Britain, campaigners from the pro-remain group have been making a splash in the media on how Brexit could damage the NHS. Simon Stevens, CEO of NHS England, was one of the latest industry leader to warn the public that the sustainability of the health service could be greatly undermined in the event of an exit due to the impact on public finances of the anticipated economic shock

As campaign groups fire out claims and counter-claims on the realities of EU membership on the NHS, it is worrying that the health service seems to be part of their main strategy to engage with the public, particularly when it is used as a tool to scaremonger. Given the high political stakes, it is not surprising that campaigners are capitalising on the fondness the public have for the NHS by making it a core issue. However, it is of utmost importance that the public aren’t just presented with spin that only serves to position campaigners as the true champions of the NHS. The EU has a subtle and far-reaching effect on the health sector which is much broader than the pure economic arguments. 

Public unaware of the impact the EU has on health

Worryingly, a ComRes opinion poll for CIPFA shows that the public seem to be unaware of the impact the EU has on health, with nearly half of those polled (46%) believing that membership of the EU makes no difference to health delivery. 

In comparison, leaders in the sector, in separate independently conducted in-depth interviews CIPFA commissioned, reflected a far stronger opinion. Indeed, 19 out of 20 interviewees, which comprised CFOs and CEOs, said the benefits the EU has on public services outweigh any drawbacks. 

One of the principle reasons for their support of the EU was their appreciation of networks between EU members. They praised these networks as powering research and allowing for the exchange of ideas, which is critical to evidence-based healthcare. These networks also provide the opportunity for healthcare professionals to learn how services operate in other member states, with interviewees stating they had often been inspired by these different governance, funding and delivery models. 

In 2011, the Coalition government praised this kind of collaboration and its significant positive impact on research. In its ‘Balance of Competences’ report, it highlighted how collective public health research between member states has helped tackle tobacco addiction, alcohol abuse and other health inequalities. 

In the next few years, the EU will implement policies to tackle obesity at a European level. As illnesses caused by obesity costs the NHS an estimated £6.3bn to treat in 2015, any work to try and alleviate this pressure is positive. 

So-called ‘lifestyle’ diseases are widely acknowledged as being partly responsible for an increase in service demand. Immigration is also strongly perceived as another contributing factor through the impact of health tourism, which is made easier by Freedom of Movement policies within the EU. However, those interviewed as part of our research, cited immigration and its impact on free movement of workers as beneficial to the health and social care sector – pointing out the significant boost healthcare professionals from other member states have made to the sector’s workforce. There is the concern about how the sector would cope without this source of skills and expertise in the event of a ‘Brexit’. 

Indeed, figures from the TUC estimate that approximately 50,000 migrants from the European Economic Area (EEA) work in the NHS, representing around 4.5% of the total workforce. Considering the Public Accounts Committee has issued concerns on staff shortages, which it estimates to be around 50,000, any further reduction in numbers could cause significant difficulties in the delivery of services. Health provider budgets, which overspent by £2.45bn in 2015-16, would be stretched even further to fund larger numbers of locum and agency staff. 

However, it is a matter of conjecture on whether the NHS would lose staff if the UK were to ‘Brexit’. It may be the case that the UK would still have to participate in the Free Movement Policy as a condition of any UK-EU trade agreements. Indeed, that has been one of the principle issues of considering ‘Brexit’ – nobody can say for certain exactly how things would work outside of the EU. 

As the Referendum draws closer, it is important that these unknowns are addressed. Considering the lack of public awareness on how the EU affects the public sector, the absence of objective information is a great concern. This is one of the most significant decisions in a generation, which must be made on evidence rather than spin!

Tell us what you think – have your say below or email


Mari Munro   20/06/2016 at 13:39

Yet another Brexit story about the end of life as we know it. Similar claims have been made about workers rights and sharing of security and police information. Are we really to believe that we would be incapable of maintaining or even improving our current employment and security exchange arrangements. Many big businesses see Brexit as an opportunity to access skilled workers such as engineers from the global market rather than restrict ourselves to the EU.

Rupert Fawdry   20/06/2016 at 13:56

Thanks for the excellent combination of the Union Flag with the EU flag. Having overlaid it with the words "In our one world, We need to Build Bridges, Not Walls", a printed out version now adorns my car and home windows. Wish I had had it sooner.

Anne Reynolds   20/06/2016 at 14:53

The main causes of pressure on NHS are closure of acute beds; closure of A & Es; underfunding by government; top heavy management and, equally, a massive increase in the population due to uncontrolled immigration. The reason doctors and nursing staff vacancies are filled by non british born people is due to lack of UK training places, and with inside knowledge, because it is cheaper to employ two qualified nurses from abroad than it is to renew existing contracts for qualified, experienced, British born staff. Many British born residents train and qualify only to find there is no job waiting for them at the end! Check the figures for yourselves. It is a multi-complex issue without one clear solution, but preventing the possible influx of another few million EU migrants over the coming years by voting Leave, will be part of the solution to reducing the unbearable pressure on our hospital and medical staff.

Add your comment


national health executive tv

more videos >

latest healthcare news

Highest ever numbers accept GP training posts

19/10/2018Highest ever numbers accept GP training posts

The number of people entering GP training is the highest in NHS history, according to new figures from Health Education England (HEE). A tot... more >
‘No realistic prospect of progress’ for integrated health and social care, PAC warns

19/10/2018‘No realistic prospect of progress’ for integrated health and social care, PAC warns

The government is still “a long way” from achieving an effective strategy for integrated health and social care and has been urged to... more >
One in six trusts could end PFI contracts due to poor performance as NHS heads for £1bn loss

19/10/2018One in six trusts could end PFI contracts due to poor performance as NHS heads for £1bn loss

A new report has revealed that 15% of all NHS trusts using private finance initiatives (PFI) could terminate contracts due to poor performance. ... more >
Council strips contract from NHS trusts and hands it to Virgin after High Court row

18/10/2018Council strips contract from NHS trusts and hands it to Virgin after High Court row

Lancashire County Council (LCC) has awarded a controversial £104m healthcare contract to Virgin Care for the second time after a hearing in... more >


Duncan Selbie: A step on the journey to population health

24/01/2018Duncan Selbie: A step on the journey to population health

The NHS plays a part in the country’s wellness – but it’s far from being all that matters. Duncan Selbie, chief executive of Pu... more >
Cutting through the fake news

22/11/2017Cutting through the fake news

In an era of so-called ‘fake news’ growing alongside a renewed focus on reducing stigma around mental health, Paul Farmer, chief exec... more >
Tackling infection prevention locally

04/10/2017Tackling infection prevention locally

Dr Emma Burnett, a lecturer and researcher in infection prevention at the University of Dundee’s School of Nursing and Midwifery and a boar... more >
Scan4Safety: benefits across the whole supply chain

02/10/2017Scan4Safety: benefits across the whole supply chain

NHE interviews Gillian Fox, head of eProcurement (Scan4Safety) programme at NHS Supply Chain. How has the Scan4Safety initiative evolved sin... more >
Simon Stevens: A hunger for innovation

25/09/2017Simon Stevens: A hunger for innovation

Simon Stevens, chief executive of NHS England, knows that the health service is already a world leader when it comes to medical advances – ... more >

last word

Hard to be optimistic

Hard to be optimistic

Rachel Power, chief executive of the Patients Association, warns that we must be realistic about the very real effects of continued underfunding across the health service. It’s now bey... more > more last word articles >


Recoup and recover

10/10/2018Recoup and recover

The ease and round-the-clock nature of making cashless payments has transformed the way we pay for goods and services – and, from now on, t... more >
The clinical voice at the heart of procurement

10/10/2018The clinical voice at the heart of procurement

Jo Gander, director of the Clinical and Product Assurance (CaPA) team, talks about their role as part of the new NHS Supply Chain. NHS Suppl... more >
Deal or no deal?

10/10/2018Deal or no deal?

Dr Andrew Dearden, BMA treasurer and Brexit lead, takes a look at what different Brexit scenarios could means for both patients and healthcare pr... more >
A push for digital in mental health

10/10/2018A push for digital in mental health

Sean Duggan, chief executive of NHS Confederation’s Mental Health Network, argues that mental health services could hugely benefit from dig... more >

the scalpel's daily blog

On your bike!

17/10/2018On your bike!

Sathish Sethuraman, travel and transport plan co-ordinator at Northumbria Healthcare NHS FT, explains how efforts to promote cycling to work at the trust are resulting in more staff travelling on two wheels. At Northumbria Healthcare, we are committed to becoming a greener organisation and reducing the environmental impact of delivering p... more >
read more blog posts from 'the scalpel' >