Health Service Focus

25.07.17

Get ready to do it all over again

Source: NHE Jul/Aug 2017

NHE hears from Jim Mackey and Lord Carter of Coles about the ongoing efficiency challenge.

At Confed17, Jim Mackey and Simon Stevens both commended the health sector for its efforts in the past 12 months to break even financially in 2016-17. The provider sector finished the year with a deficit of £791m, but this was covered with commissioning underspends, which included an £800m risk reserve to balance the anticipated provider deficit. 

But before anyone could finish patting themselves on the back, they were promptly reminded that the NHS needs to “do it all over again” in 2017-18, and this includes further efficiencies, service redesign and taking part in initiatives like the Model Hospital and NHS RightCare.

“There has been a fantastic effort across the NHS. We managed to break even overall,” noted Mackey. “The provider system ended that £735m pre-audit in deficit, but two providers chose to defer two transactions into this financial year taking us to £791m. It is a fantastic achievement, given where people were at the end of Q3. 

“Providers delivered a cost-reduction that in virtually every system in the world is impossible. I don’t think anyone could reasonably expect any system to deliver this level of efficiency for so long, but you’ve managed to do it. Sadly, we’ve got to do it again. Overall, 91% of providers earned STF during the year, and 74% of providers managed to hit or exceed their control total.” 

He also revealed that the NHS Improvement (NHSI) will shortly publish details of financial plans, but stated that this would not be another ‘financial reset’. 

Responding to this, Chris Hopson, CEO of NHS Providers, stated that while a year-end figure of -£791m exceeds the -£580m target set by national bodies, it is substantially better than the £2.45bn deficit in 2015-16, and is a significant improvement on the third quarter forecast issued in February, which stood at -£886m. 

“This reflects a huge amount of hard work to control costs, increase productivity and improve efficiency whilst continuing to provide outstanding patient care with record levels of demand. The £700m of savings in agency staff costs is particularly notable, and is a credit to the great progress trusts have made in addressing this priority,” he said 

But the figures need to be kept in context. “NHS England funding in 2016-17 rose by 3.6% but this year that drops to 1.3%,” explained Hospon. “Two-thirds of trusts told us at quarter three that they were very or fairly reliant on one-off non-recurrent savings to meet their year-end figures. That is not sustainable.” 

Earned autonomy, CEP and change in approach 

During his final speech at Confed17 as CEO of NHSI, Mackey discussed the need to usher in a shift towards “earned autonomy” and “distributed leadership”. However, this would not take the form of earned autonomy in the old FT way but instead apply increasingly to systems of health. This was a move welcomed by Hopson, who said that trusts are ready to talk to the regulator about this. 

The change of direction also comes at a time when NHSI needs to go into a slightly different phase. “We can’t lose a grip of the money and performance, but you will see quality, hopefully, being more centre stage to our priorities,” said Mackey. 

“Obviously, there will be a lot more joined-up working with NHS England and the CQC,” he noted. “We need to be more pragmatic around transactions, and be clearer about the rules. We also need to be clearer about what support we can offer to systems, recognising that you have to deliver them.”

Mackey went on to discuss the capped expenditure process (CEP), a new regulatory intervention designed to radically and rapidly cut spending in geographical areas with the largest budget deficits, where leaders had been asked to ‘think the unthinkable’, as remaining within these new spending limits required difficult decisions over the level of care that can be provided to local patients. 

The CEP differs to existing financial controls in its focus on healthcare systems, including both commissioners and providers of healthcare, rather than individual trusts or CCGs. 

“First of all, I think everyone would understand that if a lot of the country has moved back into balance, it is very difficult to justify that parts of the country are seriously out of balance,” said Mackey. “We have to try and close the gap where necessary, and often that requires very difficult decisions.

“The CEP was an attempt to do that with people in a local system. I think that a lot of the concern hasn’t been about what, it has been about how. And about how the process has been conducted. There have been examples of perceived bad behaviour, or actual bad behaviour, and style not being how people would like to see it carried out.” 

Sustaining efficiencies 

Speaking a couple of weeks later at the Health+Care Show, Lord Carter of Coles, a non-executive director at NHSI who led the recent review into productivity in acute hospitals, stated that part of the challenge in delivering long-lasting change is “getting people to understand and accept the data”. 

“People always reject the data immediately because it doesn’t suit them,” he said. “But often the case is we can work our way through it and, gradually, unwanted variations can be sorted out. We’re beginning slowly to see it, this isn’t a rocket going up into the sky; this is a trajectory, and it is about taking people with us and making sure it happens.” 

Not wanting to focus just on clinical variations and productivity, he highlighted two areas that are receiving a lot of interest with regards to efficiency: pathology and back office. 

“It’s not to say it isn’t hard to drive change in those areas, but we have seen it,” said Lord Carter, adding that in areas like Frimley and Reading there have been enormous efficiency savings delivered. 

“This is about boots on the ground doing things, not about some strategic call on an STP. It’s about people getting out there, working with colleagues, integrating and taking the cost down,” he explained.

Lord Carter, who is also leading a productivity review into mental health, community and ambulance trusts, added that while acute services are looking to make savings in their areas there is also scope to reduce unwarranted variations in other settings. 

“We’re going to be publishing some information on that,” he said, reflecting that there may need to be a greater education of the local population with regards to the cost of some community services. 

“Up and down the country we have small community hospitals which are popular in the communities they serve,” noted Lord Carter. “But sometimes we should point out to those communities that a bed can cost up to £210,000 a year, and ask is that money well spent?

“How do we educate our populations to actually make the right choices? I find it rather strange that people are prepared to drive 60 miles to an Ikea to get their table leg fixed, but they aren’t prepared to go 30 miles to get their own leg fixed. We do have a problem, of actually what we might reasonably expect from our populations if we are to get first-class healthcare.” 

Discussing the Model Hospital and the productivity programme, the the Labour Peer said the regulator is  going to continue to push information out into the system to make sure that people know it’s happening and that the programme is beginning to work. 

“The danger will be, we won’t get it sustained, it will become a one-off and we’ll run off and do something else. We have to actually push over that, we have to make sure pathology consolidation occurs. And it’s difficult, hospitals do not want to give up their labs, they see it as the first move into consolidation and their services being removed,” he explained. “And the pressure we’ll face all the time is, when do we ask and when do we tell? And that’s the thing we’re going to need guidance on. Because sometimes the greater good requires people to give things up, which instinctively they would not do unless there was some pressure applied. A very, very difficult task for NHSI and NHS England going forward.

 

“What you want to hear from people like us is how we’re going to fix it, and that’s what we’re determined to do. I don’t want to come back next year and say, ‘we haven’t made any progress’. And it is incumbent upon NHSI to actually provide that guidance and make sure that things are there to help. 

“What’s critical for us is to demonstrate that we’re there, we’re going to support you, and it goes forward. Efficiency is an everyday thing, and what you see, as I said in the past, is that these things can be episodic; we get excited, then we move onto the next thing. If there’s one great thing that will come out of this, we just have to make the pursuit of this excellence, both in quality as we’re seeing but also in operational efficiency, an everyday thing, it’s not a one-time effort.” 

He argued that NHSI, which is going through leadership change, will need to continue the excellent work Mackey has done. 

“I think it’s critical that the work with NHS England strengthens,” he said, but added that the important issue is how to focus those resources in NHSI in helping people, getting the information into people’s hands, and then having quite robust discussions sometimes about the choices. 

“These aren’t going to be easy, but you could argue, and I think I would, that if you look forward into the next 120 weeks, you can make significant progress” explained Lord Carter. “We’ve got to strike the balance between the continual improvement that we need and actually living the reality of everyday life in a very stretched system. I think people have done incredibly well. If I had said to providers five years ago ‘you’ll be taking £3bn a year out’, I’d be laughed out of the room. You have done it, people have risen to the challenge. As ever we’d like a little more, but this isn’t something we can’t do, because we’ve already done it.”

“WE’VE GOT TO STRIKE THE BALANCE BETWEEN THE CONTINUAL IMPROVEMENT THAT WE NEED AND ACTUALLY LIVING THE REALITY OF EVERYDAY LIFE IN A VERY STRETCHED SYSTEM”

TELL US WHAT YOU THINK

opinion@nationalhealthexecutive.com

Comments

There are no comments. Why not be the first?

Add your comment

 

national health executive tv

more videos >

latest healthcare news

Lord Kerslake quits as trust chair in protest against NHS underfunding

11/12/2017Lord Kerslake quits as trust chair in protest against NHS underfunding

Lord Kerslake has resigned as the chairman of a major hospital trust in London in protest against historic underfunding in the NHS. The respect... more >
CQC praises ‘proactive’ Hartlepool services in care integration review

08/12/2017CQC praises ‘proactive’ Hartlepool services in care integration review

The CQC had praise for the health and care system in Hartlepool as it continued its programme of 20 targeted reviews of integrated care. The... more >
Government launches inquiry into Ian Paterson case

08/12/2017Government launches inquiry into Ian Paterson case

A national inquiry has been launched into the malpractice of Ian Paterson. Earlier this year the breast surgeon was sentenced to 20 years in pri... more >

editor's comment

25/09/2017A hotbed of innovation

This edition of NHE comes hot on the heels of this year’s NHS Expo which, once again, proved to be a huge success at Manchester Central. A number of announcements were made during the event, with the health secretary naming the second wave of NHS digital pioneers, or ‘fast followers’, which follow the initial global digital e... read more >

last word

The Refugee Doctor Initiative

The Refugee Doctor Initiative

Terry John, co-chair of the BMA & BDA Refugee Doctors and Dentists Liaison Group and chair of the union’s international committee, talks about a brilliant initiative that is proving mut... more > more last word articles >
681 149x260 NHE Subscribe button

the scalpel's daily blog

Ten lessons to support new care models locally

29/11/2017Ten lessons to support new care models locally

Anna Starling, policy fellow at the Health Foundation, offers the top 10 lessons for local leaders seeking to make systematic improvements across services, all based on first-hand accounts from vanguard officials. Redesigning health and social care services across traditional boundaries is not easy. Making change in complex environments, with differing professional viewpoints and varying organisational priorities while getting on with t... more >
read more blog posts from 'the scalpel' >

comment

The equality equation that doesn’t add up

29/11/2017The equality equation that doesn’t add up

There’s a theory that innovation springs from embracing and valuing our differences, so why do we sometimes behave as though diversity of t... more >
CQC: Beyond traditional boundaries

29/11/2017CQC: Beyond traditional boundaries

Professor Ted Baker, chief inspector of hospitals at the CQC, discusses the mixed findings of this year’s major State of Care report. ... more >
A balancing act: commissioning in the new world of accountable care

29/11/2017A balancing act: commissioning in the new world of accountable care

Ruth Robertson, policy fellow at the King’s Fund, considers how CCG responsibilities and relationships will change and evolve as the NHS mo... more >
Mortimer: Waterproofing the NHS workforce

22/11/2017Mortimer: Waterproofing the NHS workforce

With the NHS facing worker shortages, tight budgets and major recruitment issues, Danny Mortimer, chief executive of NHS Employers, explains how ... more >
Realising the power of data

22/11/2017Realising the power of data

Nick Hirst, chief information officer at the National Institute for Health Research (NIHR) Clinical Research Network, outlines how his organisati... more >

interviews

Cutting through the fake news

22/11/2017Cutting through the fake news

In an era of so-called ‘fake news’ growing alongside a renewed focus on reducing stigma around mental health, Paul Farmer, chief exec... more >
Tackling infection prevention locally

04/10/2017Tackling infection prevention locally

Dr Emma Burnett, a lecturer and researcher in infection prevention at the University of Dundee’s School of Nursing and Midwifery and a boar... more >
Scan4Safety: benefits across the whole supply chain

02/10/2017Scan4Safety: benefits across the whole supply chain

NHE interviews Gillian Fox, head of eProcurement (Scan4Safety) programme at NHS Supply Chain. How has the Scan4Safety initiative evolved sin... more >
Simon Stevens: A hunger for innovation

25/09/2017Simon Stevens: A hunger for innovation

Simon Stevens, chief executive of NHS England, knows that the health service is already a world leader when it comes to medical advances – ... more >
Improving care at the touch of a screen

08/08/2017Improving care at the touch of a screen

When it comes to dementia, having a calm and safe environment can have a substantial impact on a patient’s quality of life. NHE’s Jos... more >