Designing services properly

Terry Young, professor of healthcare systems at Brunel University London and a founder of the Cumberland Initiative, argues that we should drop service improvement and just design services properly.

With a new government, the political discussion about how much commitment each party will demonstrate through its NHS spending has reached a lull. So, what questions are worth asking now? 

For instance, is the consensus correct that the care we want must always cost more – more than we are currently paying, maybe more than we want to pay, perhaps more than we can ever pay? This question is not primarily a medical question nor even a political one. The people who generally wrestle with questions such as these are engineers and even entrepreneurs.

The mobile phone is an excellent example of something that was designed to fit the pocket (physically and financially), where the vision ran well ahead of our ability to deliver, but where consistent work over decades delivered a minor miracle. Early portable phones were dominated by the battery: who can forget the yuppies of the 1980s with bricks pressed to their ears? But every part of the now ubiquitous gadget was beyond our reach: batteries, computing power, touchscreens, high-resolution graphics, accelerometers and satellite navigation. 

It took more than engineering to design such superb functionality into an affordable weight budget, size budget, power budget and, of course, financial budget. It took business-engineering to realise that the product would only pay for itself if people were really buying something else – entertainment! It looks obvious now, but thinking the challenge through from the other side was sublimely imaginative, prescient and very, very clever. 

If the seven decades since the founding of the NHS have taught us anything, it is that trying to buy more or better care provision is unaffordable. Not only that, but the system becomes so complex that we run out of capacity to manage it. 

Looking at the challenge differently 

At the Cumberland Initiative, we are committed to looking from the other side: instead of asking how much it will cost to improve, why not ask what we really want and then design the service to fit with the time we have at a cost we can afford? This is the engineering ideal: to get what we want, when we want, for what we can pay. 

Over the past six months, we have encouraged clinical and academic leaders to reflect, in different ways, upon the challenge that faces the NHS and why it is struggling to rise to it this time. Although their blogs were never intended as a systematic analysis, together they provide a surprisingly coherent contribution. 

In January, Professor Matthew Cooke, an emergency physician with NHS Improvement, asked why basic operations management fails so often to reach the emergency department ‘The wait’. He observes much willingness to copy successful initiatives, but detects a lack of rigour in working out what made the successes successful. And he notes how a dependence on initiatives has prevented attitudes, behaviour and culture – his ABCs – from becoming permanently embedded in the service.

the wait blog

Dr Steve Allder, a consultant neurologist, goes further in May ‘Built in a day?’, by asking whether the system conceptualises the process of setting up a strategy in an adequate manner. He observes that healthcare does not even recognise that the method of developing strategy is an important question in its own right. Other sectors routinely adopt the formal process of identifying an overall aim, asking what conditions have created the opportunity and what capability the system has and must acquire to respond and deliver the proposed solution. He argues that such basics are critically important to healthcare strategy because the challenge ahead is so much harder than those typically faced in other sectors. 

And then in June, Lord Darzi, consultant surgeon and former health minister ‘The model-driven hospital’, draws attention to the way that other sectors have aligned the way they deliver their services with their information systems, so that information is ready where and when it is needed, and where people follow procedures that make the most of the information processing provided.

 model hospital darzi

These medical thinkers are all pointing in the same direction – to a set of management skills and technologies that are either absent or poorly applied in healthcare. In other sectors, these tools and methods are used to specify what is required and to create a service that does what is specified within budget and on time.

As an academic and coming from a very different angle, Prof Davina Allen from Cardiff wrote in May Safeguarding Quality or Papering over the cracks?’ about the rising levels of paperwork and the way in which paper trails are increasingly regarded as the guarantors of quality. Interestingly, she notes that paperwork does change services, it is just that the changes are not always what was planned.

 papering over the cracks

One of my contributions, following a visit to healthcare innovators in Australia, was to read up on a famous Australian innovator in engineering and warfare, General Sir John Monash ‘Over the top?’.  His ability to envisage the progress of a battle in advance, plan in detail, and then co-ordinate a range of resources to achieve his ends, was a revelation to British generals and enabled him to reach all his objectives just three minutes after the 90 minutes he had planned for the Battle of Hamel.

blog overthetop

 So, what picture has emerged from these perspectives? Firstly, they call into question the current approach of trying steadily to improve services. Not only do the services frequently fail to deliver what is required, but the mechanisms for guaranteeing quality are themselves suspect. Meanwhile the rest of the world looks at things the other way around – deciding what it needs and setting out to achieve it. As we noted with the smartphone story, the industrial journey is not necessarily cheap or even fast. But it gets there in the end.

Have you got a story to tell? Would you like to become an NHE columnist? If so, click here.


There are no comments. Why not be the first?

Add your comment


national health executive tv

more videos >

latest healthcare news

New state-of-the-art care home to open in Nottingham

18/02/2020New state-of-the-art care home to open in Nottingham

A new state-of-the-art care home is set to be opened in Nottingham by early 2021, as part of an upcoming £30m trade park development in the... more >
NHS LPP: NHS procurement a different way

18/02/2020NHS LPP: NHS procurement a different way

Managing Director of the NHS London Procurement Partnership (NHS LPP), Michael Pace, spoke with NHE’s Matt Roberts about the organisation&r... more >
NPA commissions study into frozen funding impact on pharmacies

18/02/2020NPA commissions study into frozen funding impact on pharmacies

The National Pharmacy Association (NPA) has commissioned an economic impact assessment of community pharmacy funding and policy framework in Engl... more >

the scalpel's daily blog

Unappreciated Qualities of Leadership: Hope

17/02/2020Unappreciated Qualities of Leadership: Hope

Independent consultant and strategic advisor Dean Royles continues his series on The Unappreciated Qualities of Leadership. You can find links to his previous pieces here.   Those that follow me on Twitter and Instagram will know I'm a keen hiker. I love the outdoors and I love a sunrise, full of anticipation, bringing with it the prospect of another beautiful day, another day of adventure. Because of where I live, I spen... more >
read more blog posts from 'the scalpel' >


Mike Farrar, Swim England - Last Word

07/12/2019Mike Farrar, Swim England - Last Word

Mike Farrar Chairperson of Swim England Would you talk us through your previous roles within the NHS? I’ve held a number of ... more >
Matt Hancock says GP recruitment is on the rise to support ‘bedrock of the NHS’

24/10/2019Matt Hancock says GP recruitment is on the rise to support ‘bedrock of the NHS’

Today, speaking at the Royal College of General Practitioners (RCGP) annual conference, Matt Hancock highlighted what he believes to be the three... more >
NHS dreams come true for Teesside domestic

17/09/2019NHS dreams come true for Teesside domestic

Over 20 years ago, a Teesside hospital cleaner put down her mop and took steps towards her midwifery dreams. Lisa Payne has been delivering ... more >
How can winter pressures be dealt with? Introduce a National Social Care Service, RCP president suggests

24/10/2018How can winter pressures be dealt with? Introduce a National Social Care Service, RCP president suggests

A dedicated national social care service could be a potential solution to surging demand burdening acute health providers over the winter months,... more >

last word

Haseeb Ahmad: ‘We all have a role to play in getting innovations quicker’

Haseeb Ahmad: ‘We all have a role to play in getting innovations quicker’

Haseeb Ahmad, president of the Association of the British Pharmaceutical Industry (ABPI), sits down with National Health Executive as part of our Last Word Q&A series. Would you talk us th... more > more last word articles >

editor's comment

25/09/2017A hotbed of innovation

This edition of NHE comes hot on the heels of this year’s NHS Expo which, once again, proved to be a huge success at Manchester Central. A number of announcements were made during the event, with the health secretary naming the second wave of NHS digital pioneers, or ‘fast followers’, which follow the initial global digital e... read more >

health service focus

NHS LPP: NHS procurement a different way

18/02/2020NHS LPP: NHS procurement a different way

Managing Director of the NHS London Procureme... more >
CAMHS: The state of play for children and adolescent mental health

14/02/2020CAMHS: The state of play for children and adolescent mental health

National Health Executive’s Matt Robert... more >