Comment

13.02.17

Outsourcing will not be the panacea for the NHS funding crisis

Source: NHE Jan/Feb 17

Vivek Kotecha from the Centre for Health and the Public Interest (CHPI) considers the argument for and against greater outsourcing in the NHS.

In England, a recent addition to the list of Christmas traditions (mulled wine, Christmas pudding, carols and crackers) seems to be an annual NHS winter crisis. The fear is that that what was once only a winter crisis is at risk of becoming a year-round fixture, exacerbated by the £22bn shortfall between NHS funding and the cost of meeting healthcare needs by 2020. 

To address these concerns, England has been split into 44 geographical ‘footprints’ and in each one a team drawn from hospital trusts, CCGs and local councils, assisted by staff from NHS England’s regional teams and planning consultants from the private sector, have published sustainability and transformation plans (STPs). These aim to set out how they will provide healthcare until 2020-21 whilst contributing their share of the spending cuts needed to meet the £22bn shortfall. The scale of the cost savings needed has necessitated ambitious proposals and rethinks of how healthcare is provided. 

One option that will be considered to cut costs further is the contracting out of NHS services to independent providers, the voluntary sector and local authorities. This seems likely because the use of outsourcing has steadily grown over recent years and many of the services that could be outsourced are non-tariff, i.e. there is no fixed price per treatment and so bidders can compete on price. In 2015-16, £12.2bn was spent on non-NHS providers (10.7% of the Department of Health’s expenditure limit), up from £4.4bn in 2005-06 (5.8% of the expenditure limit). The use of non-NHS providers has been growing since the 1990s, but the question is: does the NHS have the capability to effectively outsource services without compromising on quality? 

Outsourcing is not the same as privatisation 

It is important to note that outsourcing is not the same as privatisation. Privatisation is usually a complete and permanent transfer of the governance, control, and operating risk of an asset or service to a private provider, whilst outsourcing usually involves transferring responsibility for managing an asset (but not ownership of it), or providing a service to a private provider for a finite contractual period. 

The arguments for outsourcing rest on the different incentives that operate in the private and public sectors. Studies by economists have found that outsourcing does generally lead to cost savings (estimates range from 6-20%), but these are of similar magnitude regardless of whether a private or public body wins the contract. This suggests that private firms aren’t necessarily more efficient than public bodies, which raises the question: how are these savings achieved? 

One hypothesis is that quality of service is reduced in order to cut costs. There is evidence of this taking place and it is most common in contracts of services where quality is a subjective judgement and performance hard to monitor. For example, what counts as a high standard of cleanliness varies from one person to another. A recent study has found that outsourced cleaning services are associated with lower costs but a higher incidence of MRSA. This is an example of how savings made must be weighed against any impact on quality and safety. 

Another hypothesis suggests that cost savings are achieved at the expense of workers’ pay and conditions. There is mixed evidence, but even if actual pay rates don’t drop, work intensity does increase and the likelihood of industrial accidents or repetitive strain injury – and injuries to patients or users of social care – goes up too. 

For the NHS these are important considerations as healthcare is a service industry, and if quality is compromised directly or indirectly through overworked staff, the risk of harm to patients increases. The aim of outsourcing may be cost minimisation but not at the expense of service quality. So what are the characteristics of a successfully outsourced contract? 

Outsourcing works best when contracts can be complete, i.e. when they account in advance for different future scenarios such as higher than expected demand; when they can clearly allocate risk between the contracting parties; and when they have goals that are realistic to monitor and enforce. A good example of an easy to outsource service is refuse collection. Generally, they are complete (most scenarios can be predicted, such as more homes to collect from, or adverse weather), risk can be easily shared (the collector is responsible for collecting the refuse), and it is easy to monitor (residents can see if their refuse is not being collected). 

In healthcare it is a lot harder to meet these conditions. More complex tasks (such as providing GP services or community care) are now being outsourced. Quality is often hard to measure and enforce for these services. Analysis by the CHPI has shown that contracting out by NHS bodies is often not effective because they lack the expertise to negotiate terms, don’t have the capacity to monitor performance, and are often reluctant to punish failure due to a dependence on the provider because of a lack of alternatives. Worse yet, they might create incentives for providers of outsourced services to engage in fraudulent behaviour. 

One example is Serco’s out-of-hours GP contract in Cornwall, where performance targets were falsified and the service was short-staffed. Performance was not scrutinised and when concerns were raised no fines were made by the NHS body for fear of making the service worse. 

As 2017 progresses and STPs look to make up for the £22bn funding shortfall the temptation to outsource more services will grow. However, the increasing complexity and need for quality in the services not yet outsourced, along with the lack of monitoring capacity in CCGs and hospital trusts, makes the benefits of outsourcing less likely to materialise.

FOR MORE INFORMATION

W: https://chpi.org.uk

Comments

There are no comments. Why not be the first?

Add your comment

 

national health executive tv

more videos >

latest healthcare news

Three CCGs slapped with NHS England legal directions

18/08/2017Three CCGs slapped with NHS England legal directions

Three CCGs have been slapped with NHS England legal directions requiring them to produce urgent improvement and financial plans, as well as hire ... more >
Numbers placed into nursing courses drops by 8% since 2016

18/08/2017Numbers placed into nursing courses drops by 8% since 2016

Nurses have today warned that there are not enough new workers being trained to keep pace with demand as UCAS figures showed that there had been ... more >
London trust told to improve for third time in three years

17/08/2017London trust told to improve for third time in three years

A major London NHS trust has been told by inspectors that it needs to urgently improve after it received its third ‘Requires Improvement&rs... more >
681 149x260 NHE Subscribe button

the scalpel's daily blog

Turbo-boosting STPs? It’s time we got serious about ‘partnership’

27/07/2017Turbo-boosting STPs? It’s time we got serious about ‘partnership’

Merron Simpson, chief executive New NHS Alliance, argues we’re missing the point of what ‘partnership working’ truly means if we refuse to recruit help from those outside the health service. Jeremy Hunt and Simon Steven’s recent announcement to ‘turbo-boost’ sustainability and transformation partnerships (STPs) provides a welcome shot-in-the-arm for those across the system who are ... more >
read more blog posts from 'the scalpel' >

interviews

Improving care at the touch of a screen

08/08/2017Improving care at the touch of a screen

When it comes to dementia, having a calm and safe environment can have a substantial impact on a patient’s quality of life. NHE’s Jos... more >
A new approach to talent management

25/07/2017A new approach to talent management

Martin Hancock, national lead for talent management at NHS Leadership Academy, and Gill Rooke, the organisation’s senior operations manager... more >
Enabling greater integration through ACSs

25/07/2017Enabling greater integration through ACSs

At this year’s NHS Confed, Simon Stevens revealed the first wave of accountable care systems (ACSs). NHE speaks to Ian Dodge, the director ... more >
How NHS organisations can protect themselves against cyber crime

25/07/2017How NHS organisations can protect themselves against cyber crime

On 12 May, a global cyber-attack occurred on an unprecedented scale. It affected organisations across the globe and, though it did not specifical... more >

last word

Your personality, your leadership

Your personality, your leadership

Deirdre Wallace, clinical skills manager at UCL Medical School, discusses the importance of learning about leadership and self while at medical school. Approximately five years ago, I was ch... more > more last word articles >

editor's comment

13/06/2017Tackling the major challenges facing the NHS

As you will have gathered from the front cover, a theme that runs throughout this edition of NHE is about empowering and involving the workforce in order to deliver innovative change across the system.  Professor Jane Dacre, president of the Royal College of Physicians, highlights on page 16 the importance of sustainability and trans... read more >

health service focus

Securing the health service with openness and transparency

08/08/2017Securing the health service with openness and transparency

Mike Lees, head of business security at Barns... more >
Transforming health and care: the Dorset story

08/08/2017Transforming health and care: the Dorset story

Phil Richardson, Dorset STP lead director, ex... more >