interviews

25.07.17

Enabling greater integration through ACSs

Source: NHE Jul/Aug 2017

At this year’s NHS Confed, Simon Stevens revealed the first wave of accountable care systems (ACSs). NHE speaks to Ian Dodge, the director responsible for NHS England’s strategy and policy, about the developments and direction of travel.

Shortly before the general election was called, which seems somewhat in the dim and distant past, NHS England launched its ‘Next Steps on the NHS Five Year Forward View (FYFV)’ document. It outlined a number of key policy areas and gave the sector an update on STPs and the move towards more ‘evolved’ ACSs. 

The document, once again, reiterated the direction of travel in that across England, “commissioners and providers across the NHS and local government need to work closely together – to improve the health and wellbeing of their local population and make best use of available funding”. 

Speaking to NHE following the general election, and after Simon Stevens unveiled the first wave of ACSs, Ian Dodge, the director responsible for NHS England’s strategy and policy, said that “when money is increasingly tight, there is something about how systems come together more effectively to work through some of the difficult decisions collectively – rather than lots and lots of energy being spent battling against each other in a battle of the spreadsheets”. 

Stefan Rousseau - PA Wire edit

Discussing the FYFV update document, Dodge added that NHS England wants to enable new and more integrated forms of provision to emerge, but there is still work to do. 

“If you look at our health system compared to a number of other international systems, then the boundary between what providers do and what commissioners do could move a little bit more in line with those international models,” he said. 

“If you look at what has been done with things like the New Care Models programme, it is absolutely working on that bit of provider development, and how the different services come together to deliver the best place-based services in local populations while dealing with the challenges of rising demand, adopting new technologies and making the best use of the workforce.”

 Living within the legal framework 

During Confed17, NHS Improvement’s CEO Jim Mackey stated that that it is possible to get “90% of the way there” with ACSs and accountable care organisations within the current legislative framework – “but we need to prove it”. This came after health secretary Jeremy Hunt suggested that legislation around STPs is likely to be pushed until after Brexit negotiations are concluded. And even then, it is questionable whether the government will be able to legislate without cross-party support for its reform programme. 

Asked about the legal constraints surrounding STPs and ACSs, Dodge said: “The job of NHS England is to live within the legislative framework that Parliament has set. There has been speculation as to whether there would be primary legislation, and the Conservatives’ manifesto alluded to that prospect. I think others have speculated that this would be less likely now given the current status of politics. 

“Obviously, the Department of Health had been talking to its partners as to possible legislative change. Should the government wish to engage further at some stage we will offer our input. But we must do as much as we can to deliver within the existing legislative framework.” 

There is a lot that people can do within the current framework, noted Dodge, who helped set up the New Models Care programme and some of the work on STPs — “but the most important thing is getting the relationships right and then getting on with the service design”. 

“Arguably, we can all fixate a little bit too much on the anatomy of the health service and a little bit less when we need to focus more on the physiology of how it all connects,” he said. 

The NHS England director added that the work already undertaken as part of the reform agenda, in terms of looking at how to support the optimal planning of services and providing some of the challenge around redesign, tackling variation and improving outcomes, has to continue – irrespective of any technical changes in the system. 

No single answer on CCG mergers 

One potential technical change, for instance, is further CCG mergers. “On one level, what we are doing with things like the STP process and devolution is saying, ‘actually it is quite a hard job for individual CCGs to do everything perfectly entirely by themselves’. They need to engage their local authority partners, their core providers, including acute providers, in developing their vision of where they want to get to and executing against that,” said Dodge. 

Asked whether there will be more CCG mergers to facilitate greater collaboration across footprints, Dodge stated that NHS England doesn’t have a view that there is a single right answer across the country on this. 

“I know that some people have found that hard to believe, and that there must be a secret kind of plan here and that we have a magic number in mind,” he said. “But we don’t have a magic number. But there are trade-offs in getting the local relationships right in places and getting the geographies right around some of the challenges. 

“Those dilemmas apply differently across different services. For example, you need to plan hyper-specialist services on a different footprint from, say, other specialist services differently from a lot of A&E services, differently from your integrated primary and community hubs. The art is partly about how we can plan and commission services at those right levels. What we have tried to do is avoid a headlong rush into people thinking the answer is to merge, because that could potentially be a big deflection. But equally, we haven’t wanted to stand in the way when there are compelling reasons to merge – hence the very clear criteria we set out. 

“We are also, naturally, seeing the emergence of the sharing of management functions between CCGs and an increasing number of shared management teams. If you go talk to NHS Clinical Commissioners, that is exactly the right direction of travel.” 

One thing that ACSs have been tasked with is how to join up the local budget in a meaningful way across the footprint, extending the work that CCGs have been doing in their areas. 

“We need to look at how we can take that work, and progress it in a way that feels more meaningful to the ACSs,” said Dodge. “We’ve also noted that there is an element of ‘horses for courses’ for each of the individual systems. 

“One of the emerging templates is the work that we have done with Greater Manchester  (GM) with regards to devolution. If you take away the devo wrapper and instead take the underlying principles of what that has been about –  how can we transfer more clearly a sense of responsibility for managing the local system, how can we support the horizontal integration, the vertical integration, and the sense of local systems coming together – what we are doing with ACSs is very similar to what is going on in GM.

“This will get codified in an agreement between the national organisations and the local ACSs and what responsibilities they take on at different stages. There is a development group, so we are co-designing this work with the ACSs that Simon announced at Confed and what this means for them and when. At the end of the day, our aim here is to enable.”

First wave of ACSs 

  • Frimley Health
  • South Yorkshire & Bassetlaw
  • Nottinghamshire
  • Blackpool & Fylde Coast
  • Dorset, Luton (with Milton Keynes and Bedfordshire)
  • West Berkshire
  • Buckinghamshire
  • Devo Surrey

TELL US WHAT YOU THINK

opinion@nationalhealthexecutive.com

Image - © Stefan Rousseau - PA Wire

Comments

There are no comments. Why not be the first?

Add your comment

 

national health executive tv

more videos >

latest healthcare news

Lord Kerslake quits as trust chair in protest against NHS underfunding

11/12/2017Lord Kerslake quits as trust chair in protest against NHS underfunding

Lord Kerslake has resigned as the chairman of a major hospital trust in London in protest against historic underfunding in the NHS. The respect... more >
CQC praises ‘proactive’ Hartlepool services in care integration review

08/12/2017CQC praises ‘proactive’ Hartlepool services in care integration review

The CQC had praise for the health and care system in Hartlepool as it continued its programme of 20 targeted reviews of integrated care. The... more >
Government launches inquiry into Ian Paterson case

08/12/2017Government launches inquiry into Ian Paterson case

A national inquiry has been launched into the malpractice of Ian Paterson. Earlier this year the breast surgeon was sentenced to 20 years in pri... more >
681 149x260 NHE Subscribe button

the scalpel's daily blog

Ten lessons to support new care models locally

29/11/2017Ten lessons to support new care models locally

Anna Starling, policy fellow at the Health Foundation, offers the top 10 lessons for local leaders seeking to make systematic improvements across services, all based on first-hand accounts from vanguard officials. Redesigning health and social care services across traditional boundaries is not easy. Making change in complex environments, ... more >
read more blog posts from 'the scalpel' >

comment

The equality equation that doesn’t add up

29/11/2017The equality equation that doesn’t add up

There’s a theory that innovation springs from embracing and valuing our differences, so why do we sometimes behave as though diversity of t... more >
CQC: Beyond traditional boundaries

29/11/2017CQC: Beyond traditional boundaries

Professor Ted Baker, chief inspector of hospitals at the CQC, discusses the mixed findings of this year’s major State of Care report. ... more >
A balancing act: commissioning in the new world of accountable care

29/11/2017A balancing act: commissioning in the new world of accountable care

Ruth Robertson, policy fellow at the King’s Fund, considers how CCG responsibilities and relationships will change and evolve as the NHS mo... more >
Mortimer: Waterproofing the NHS workforce

22/11/2017Mortimer: Waterproofing the NHS workforce

With the NHS facing worker shortages, tight budgets and major recruitment issues, Danny Mortimer, chief executive of NHS Employers, explains how ... more >

last word

The Refugee Doctor Initiative

The Refugee Doctor Initiative

Terry John, co-chair of the BMA & BDA Refugee Doctors and Dentists Liaison Group and chair of the union’s international committee, talk... more > more last word articles >

editor's comment

25/09/2017A hotbed of innovation

This edition of NHE comes hot on the heels of this year’s NHS Expo which, once again, proved to be a huge success at Manchester Central. A number of announcements were made during the event, with the health secretary naming the second wave of NHS digital pioneers, or ‘fast followers’, which follow the initial global digital e... read more >

health service focus

Release full market value against surplus and decommissioned assets

28/11/2017Release full market value against surplus and decommissioned assets

Advertisement feature: Oliver Pearson, sal... more >
Operation Barcode: selecting technology to succeed

22/11/2017Operation Barcode: selecting technology to succeed

The benefits of Scan4Safety have been widely ... more >