Last Word

22.03.17

Foreign patient charges are a distraction from the real issues

Vivek Kotecha, research officer at the Centre for Health and the Public Interest (CHPI), explains why the charging of foreign patients distracts from our home-grown NHS issues. 

The Department of Health’s (DH’s) PR team must be run ragged by now with the constant stream of negative news about the NHS. In early February, the BBC and other news outlets were running a week’s worth of coverage on the growing NHS crises: bed shortages, underfunding, planned closures or downgrades of A&E departments and the impact of Brexit on EU staff. Amidst the rising crescendo of criticism of historically poor government stewardship, a positive news story was announced: foreign patients (aka ‘health tourists’) were to be charged upfront for non-urgent care. 

The tabloid press duly seized upon the chance to reprint their annual ‘health tourism’ headlines, but with the NHS being cumulatively underfunded by £54bn between now and 2021 the key questions are: how much money will it raise for the NHS? Is it an area worth focusing the NHS’s limited manpower and resources in? 

How big is the problem? 

So, firstly, how big is the scale of the problem? Reliable data is hard to find, but the DH estimated that in 2012-13 the NHS charged 65% of the total amount (£40m out of a potential £62m) it could to visitors from outside the European Economic Area (EEA), and 16% of the total amount (£49m out of £305m) from visitors from the EEA. On top of this, health tourism was estimated to cost between £70-300m a year. The upper estimate suggests a total loss (£667m) equivalent to 0.6% of the DH resource budget for that year. 

Much of this gap is due to the difficulty in assessing who is eligible for free NHS treatment. Only those who are ‘ordinarily resident’ in the UK are automatically eligible, which excludes holiday-makers, former residents living overseas, and short-term migrants. However, there’s no single document that can be used to determine who should pay and residency status can change over time. Indeed, up to half of the health tourism figure is estimated to be British citizens who live overseas (expatriates) coming back for routine NHS treatment which they should pay for. 

In July 2014, the DH set itself a target to recover £500m a year of lost overseas visitor income by 2017-18, an increase of nearly 600% on the £73m received in 2012-13. By 2017-18 it is forecast to fall short of this target, receiving £346m. This is a rise from the £289m collected in 2015-16 of which the majority (£164m) was due to a new health surcharge of up to £200 a year paid by students and temporary migrants.

To put the target in perspective, £500m is equivalent to 0.5% of DH’s 2015-16 resource budget and roughly comparable to the £433m spent on consultancy, with both dwarfed by the £4.1bn spent on agency staff. Whilst there is definite scope for improvement with charging EEA citizens (where reciprocal health charging arrangements already exist), it is telling that the majority of the amount collected so far is from a new source of income instead: the annual health surcharge. 

Effective charging requires spending on overseas visitor managers, staff training and pursuing debts. All tasks that the NHS is not well set up to do due to its ‘free at the point of use’ model and constrained by the lack of documents clearly showing entitlement for free NHS care. Whilst it is fair that overseas visitors pay for their treatment, the National Audit Office cautions that for some hospitals the cost of implementing a better charging system will outweigh the additional income received. This calls for a targeted approach, with hospitals which receive large numbers of overseas patients being sensible places to spend on effective charging systems. 

What to focus on 

So where should the NHS’s remaining resources be focused? With money so tight it is important to focus any spending on the areas with the highest cost saving/money generating value. Two areas stand out for immediate attention: consultancy and agency costs. 

With around £433m spent on consultancy last year, and larger amounts in previous years, there has been scepticism about its value for the NHS. Lord Carter, who published his efficiency review of the acute sector last year, criticised the usefulness of management consultants’ advice and recommended a more clinically-led approach to solving problems. 

Almost 70% of NHS hospital spend is on staff, and they spent £3.6bn alone on agency staff in 2015-16 (7.5% of total staff costs). NHS staff are overworked and stressed, with staff sickness rates 27% higher than in any other public sector organisations and 39% of cases citing stress and overwork as the causes. These and the desire for child-friendly schedules have driven many staff to move to agency work. Spending money on training more healthcare workers, improving working conditions and flexibility for parents could rebuild morale and save the NHS a lot of agency costs in the long term. 

The idea of health tourism being a large drain on the NHS, and offering a firm sounding solution, is attractive for press headlines. But often the best solutions, when faced with a funding gap, involve a lot more mundane but highly effective steps to improve the NHS. 

Have you got a story to tell? Would you like to become an NHE columnist? If so, click here.

Comments

There are no comments. Why not be the first?

Add your comment

 

national health executive tv

more videos >

latest healthcare news

NHS chiefs accuse NHSE of scrapping flagship targets because it can no longer meet them

20/03/2019NHS chiefs accuse NHSE of scrapping flagship targets because it can no longer meet them

Plans to scrap the flagship four-hour A&E targets have been criticised by NHS chiefs, with some accusing NHS England of trying to abandon key... more >
Private hospital in Dundee announces closure with 50 jobs to go

20/03/2019Private hospital in Dundee announces closure with 50 jobs to go

A private hospital in Dundee has announced that it will close in the summer because of falling numbers of local people paying for private insuran... more >
Inquiry hears of ‘systemic problems’ with communications at scandal-hit Glasgow Hospital

20/03/2019Inquiry hears of ‘systemic problems’ with communications at scandal-hit Glasgow Hospital

There are ‘systemic problems’ in communications between infection control nurses and other staff, MSPs have heard in an inquiry into ... more >
Staying curious with the Shadow Board Programme

20/03/2019Staying curious with the Shadow Board Programme

Kirstie Stott, director of The Inspiring Leaders Network, discusses organisational and system curiosity alongside the work of the Shadow Board Pr... more >

interviews

How can winter pressures be dealt with? Introduce a National Social Care Service, RCP president suggests

24/10/2018How can winter pressures be dealt with? Introduce a National Social Care Service, RCP president suggests

A dedicated national social care service could be a potential solution to surging demand burdening acute health providers over the winter months,... more >
RCP president on new Liverpool college building: ‘This will be a hub for clinicians in the north’

24/10/2018RCP president on new Liverpool college building: ‘This will be a hub for clinicians in the north’

The president of the Royal College of Physicians (RCP) has told NHE that the college’s new headquarters based in Liverpool will become a hu... more >
Duncan Selbie: A step on the journey to population health

24/01/2018Duncan Selbie: A step on the journey to population health

The NHS plays a part in the country’s wellness – but it’s far from being all that matters. Duncan Selbie, chief executive of Pu... more >
Cutting through the fake news

22/11/2017Cutting through the fake news

In an era of so-called ‘fake news’ growing alongside a renewed focus on reducing stigma around mental health, Paul Farmer, chief exec... more >
Tackling infection prevention locally

04/10/2017Tackling infection prevention locally

Dr Emma Burnett, a lecturer and researcher in infection prevention at the University of Dundee’s School of Nursing and Midwifery and a boar... more >

last word

Hard to be optimistic

Hard to be optimistic

Rachel Power, chief executive of the Patients Association, warns that we must be realistic about the very real effects of continued underfunding across the health service. It’s now bey... more > more last word articles >

comment

Staying curious with the Shadow Board Programme

20/03/2019Staying curious with the Shadow Board Programme

Kirstie Stott, director of The Inspiring Leaders Network, discusses organisational and system curiosity alongside the work of the Shadow Board Pr... more >
Fiction as Therapy

20/03/2019Fiction as Therapy

Elaine Bousfield of ZunTold Publishing – a press specialising in fiction for children and young people – discusses ‘Fiction as ... more >
Capturing funds for the NHS estate

20/03/2019Capturing funds for the NHS estate

Aahsan Rahman, department head of town planning at NHS Property Services (NHSPS), looks at an alternative and perhaps underutilised funding sourc... more >
The digital revolution for healthcare is now!

20/03/2019The digital revolution for healthcare is now!

Richard Corbridge, chief digital & information officer at Leeds Teaching Hospitals NHS Trust, focuses on the practices his trust has put in p... more >

the scalpel's daily blog

Personal Health Budgets: empowering individuals

20/03/2019Personal Health Budgets: empowering individuals

Jon Baker, PHBChoices director at NHS Shared Business Services (NHS SBS) believes that the extension of Personal Health Budgets (PHBs) is a great opportunity for clinical commissioning groups (CCG) to expand and improve care provision – provided that the right infrastructure is in place. The personalisation agenda is transforming ou... more >
read more blog posts from 'the scalpel' >