The Scalpel's Blog


Workforce strategy: facing the facts

Dean Royles, director of human resources and organisational development at Leeds Teaching Hospitals NHS Trust, lays bare the four truths the NHS needs to confront if it intends to develop a workforce that is truly fit for the future.

Health Education England (HEE) has commenced a consultation on a draft health and care workforce strategy for England. Good. A workforce strategy for the health and care system is something many of us have been calling for for some time.

It’s a widely-held view that the delay in producing a strategy stems from a lack of clarity on which national body is responsible for workforce planning. This in itself is a concern, but we should be pleased they have now started the ball rolling. The consultation is welcome as it is an attempt to bring the whole system together, but it is hard to see where important system players like NHS Digital, local government, Skills for Health, Skills for Care, employer bodies and trade unions have contributed and influenced the draft.

The draft strategy reiterates a number of existing initiatives like new roles and more spend in training places. However, I believe it underplays the implication of ending bursaries and the impact of a more ‘market-based’ approach to education; it has not embraced the change in how we now develop new skills for staff, nor really the future digital skills that our workforces need. In fairness, it looks like a workforce supply draft strategy.

This may be because HEE has taken the lead. To be effective and meaningful as a strategy it will have to address the demand side of the equation. If we keep planning for current challenges and problems, we will never create a sustainable future. The current workforce crisis in the sector is more of a product of an inability to implement agreed, sensible service changes and improved patient pathways than it is about poor workforce planning. Adoption of new ways of working that the ‘start-up’ ecosystem is teaching us is yet to be considered. For many professions, a job is not for life: it’s for the time that the person wants to do it for. This will inevitably exacerbate the tension between sector workforce plans and organisational workforce plans.

As the health and care system responds to the consultation, I believe there are four truths we need to confront.

Truth 1: The social care workforce and the NHS workforce are inexplicably linked

The draft strategy (136 pages) devotes over 30 pages to the NHS clinical workforce, five pages to the adult social care workforce, and two paragraphs to the non-clinical workforce.  The most startling aspect of the document highlights that there are 42,000 clinical vacancies in the NHS and 88,000 vacancies in adult social care – more than double the NHS vacancies. 

What we need is an urgent clarification of what these vacancies would be if we had all our patients in the right place. If our delayed transfer of care (DTOC) and medically optimised patients were in more appropriate care setting, these numbers would be very different. Have we significantly underestimated the size of the recruitment challenges in social care?  How much do we need to grow the social care workforce and skills to keep people well and supported at home? If we are not crystal-clear about this, the strategy will be answering the wrong question and opening the health system up to still further challenges.

Truth 2: Workforce planning is not a variable balancing planning statistic

The draft document rightly points out that service, finance and workforce need to be aligned. In practice, what happens is that organisations are set a central, usually yearly, financial control total. Incentives to achieve this control total make it a ‘must do.’ The organisation then makes an assessment of likely service demand and activity and the workforce number becomes a balancing figure between the two. This is not alignment.

Realistic expectation of the available workforce needs to inform control totals and possible activity. A 10-year, radical, patient-led workforce plan is incompatible with an annual financial control total. The delivery of health and the workforce required to achieve this needs to be addressed not just as an organisational priority, but as an imperative linked to quality – not simple financial outturn measures.

Truth 3: Digital developments such as artificial intelligence (AI) can be the drivers and the enablers of change

We are in the midst of a fourth industrial revolution. Like the three revolutions before, the digital revolution is a catalyst for change to our society and the way we see work and complete tasks.

It has been argued the change it will herald is akin to the moving from an agricultural society to a manufacturing society. Innovation is rapid, robotics, paperless patient care, telemedicine, point of care pathology testing, 3D printing and genomics are changing the way we work today.

Reviews in technology and digital skills are highlighted in the draft, but the workforce strategy needs to have this centre stage. We should be worried if organisations’ digital leaders are not knocking at the HR director’s door wanting to influence this consultation.  NHS Digital needs to be seen as part of the ‘system’ so that a workforce strategy is central to the digital strategy and vice versa. Digital skills are becoming utility skills that are expected, not nice-to-have, desirable skills.

Truth 4: The ‘back office’ is part of the frontline

It can’t be right for a national system-wide workforce strategy to effectively exclude the non-clinical workforce. It’s been said that the NHS is the UK’s largest employer of IT and informatics staff. The average EU-wide public sector organisation spends 3.2% of its budget on digital. In the financial sector this is more like 15%.

The digital revolution is transforming the way hands-on care and diagnostics are delivered from clinician to patient. The way we provide services and pay our bills impacts our local economies and the health of our population. Seeing the non-clinical workforce as something we can sort later will undermine the credibility of any strategy. Furthermore, just like clinical staff, this essential part of our workforce needs to feel valued, supported and respected. This part of our workforce is being directed to consider itself as part of the healthcare solution; at the same time, it feels excluded from a workforce strategy. We can’t miss this opportunity to help this part of our workforce move from a badly identified silo to part of the patient care solution. The term ‘back office’ is designed to undermine and belittle. We must stop using it. At the time of the WannaCry attack, the informatics back office became the frontline of services across the world.

The NHS constitution highlights that the NHS belongs to the people. ‘The people’ includes NHS and social care staff. Employers, providers and trade unions should have high expectations of a workforce strategy that will take us through to the NHS’s 80th birthday. The strategy should celebrate the now, and the next 10 years not be reflective of a workforce profile that we needed a decade ago.

(Top image c. sturti)


Sarah   28/01/2018 at 08:43

Dean Thank you for this article, great articulation of the issues across the sectors. This is a Health and Socail care issue we need to look at the workforce holistically without the artificial boundaries of government budgets. The issue of "back office" I strongly dislike this title as many do is well made. The Carter review capping this section of talented and vital workforce at 6% is yet another example of simplistic numerators dictating actual need. I welcome this review and only hope that it is allowed to be carried out thoroughly.

Peter Webster   31/01/2018 at 16:43

Great article Dean, which nails a lot of unspoken truths about the current situation, especially regarding non-clinical staff, who currently seem to be non-valued yet will become an increasingly important part of the skills mix. This should become required reading for every HR Director in the NHS, every Finance Director and, most certainly, every Government official with any say whatsoever in planning the NHS if the future.

Dean   01/02/2018 at 10:32

Sarah/Peter Thanks for taking the time to feedback. It's is really appreciated. Thank you.

Vaseem   28/02/2018 at 14:04

So true about the 'back office'. These members of staff are crucial: they bring added value to their jobs and are highly rated by clinicians as they enable us to work more efficiently. Patients also appreciate their skilled assistance but sadly they are too often deemed expendable and replaced by centralised processes

Add your comment


national health executive tv

more videos >

latest healthcare news

High Court rejects ‘hostile environment’ policy challenge from Windrush man who was refused cancer treatment

10/12/2018High Court rejects ‘hostile environment’ policy challenge from Windrush man who was refused cancer treatment

A member of the Windrush generation who was refused cancer treatment has lost a legal challenge against NHS regulations that make people who cann... more >
Nine out of 10 NHS trusts revealed to have asbestos in hospitals

10/12/2018Nine out of 10 NHS trusts revealed to have asbestos in hospitals

An investigation has found that nine out of 10 NHS trusts say they have hospitals containing asbestos. Of the 211 trusts who responded to FO... more >
‘Archaic’ and ‘absurd’ fax machines banned across the NHS

10/12/2018‘Archaic’ and ‘absurd’ fax machines banned across the NHS

The NHS has been banned from buying fax machines by the health secretary who has ordered a complete phase-out of the outdated machines by April 2... more >

editor's comment

25/09/2017A hotbed of innovation

This edition of NHE comes hot on the heels of this year’s NHS Expo which, once again, proved to be a huge success at Manchester Central. A number of announcements were made during the event, with the health secretary naming the second wave of NHS digital pioneers, or ‘fast followers’, which follow the initial global digital e... read more >

last word

Hard to be optimistic

Hard to be optimistic

Rachel Power, chief executive of the Patients Association, warns that we must be realistic about the very real effects of continued underfunding across the health service. It’s now beyond doubt or dispute, other than in government, that the NHS is inadequately funded. Even the secretary of state has argued that it will need more mon... more > more last word articles >

the scalpel's daily blog

The good, the bad, and the potential of social media

05/12/2018The good, the bad, and the potential of social media

Vicki Nash, head of policy and campaigns at Mind, assesses the impact of social media on the nation’s wellbeing. Few days go by without a story in the press about the negative effect of social media on mental health. It seems obvious: people, especially children and young people, are often seen staring at their mobile phones rather ... more >
read more blog posts from 'the scalpel' >
332 304x150 NHE Callout banner.


Are we doing enough to accelerate self-care?

05/12/2018Are we doing enough to accelerate self-care?

Dr Selwyn Hodge, co-chair of the Self Care Forum, makes the case for the further reach of self-care, and for it to be embedded into our everyday ... more >
The future of commissioning

05/12/2018The future of commissioning

Julie Wood, chief executive of NHS Clinical Commissioners, reacts to Matt Hancock’s recent comments regarding commissioning. “Co... more >
Caroline Dinenage: Quality matters

05/12/2018Caroline Dinenage: Quality matters

Care minister Caroline Dinenage MP urges health and care organisations to achieve closer collaboration to improve the quality of care and support... more >
Technology first

05/12/2018Technology first

With the latest policy document from the Department of Health and Social Care (DHSC) heralding a new ‘technology-first’ ethos for the... more >

health service focus

View all News


How can winter pressures be dealt with? Introduce a National Social Care Service, RCP president suggests

24/10/2018How can winter pressures be dealt with? Introduce a National Social Care Service, RCP president suggests

A dedicated national social care service could be a potential solution to surging demand burdening acute health providers over the winter months,... more >
RCP president on new Liverpool college building: ‘This will be a hub for clinicians in the north’

24/10/2018RCP president on new Liverpool college building: ‘This will be a hub for clinicians in the north’

The president of the Royal College of Physicians (RCP) has told NHE that the college’s new headquarters based in Liverpool will become a hu... more >
Duncan Selbie: A step on the journey to population health

24/01/2018Duncan Selbie: A step on the journey to population health

The NHS plays a part in the country’s wellness – but it’s far from being all that matters. Duncan Selbie, chief executive of Pu... more >
Cutting through the fake news

22/11/2017Cutting through the fake news

In an era of so-called ‘fake news’ growing alongside a renewed focus on reducing stigma around mental health, Paul Farmer, chief exec... more >